In describing the “true state of man” Rousseau often contradicts himself. The advantage of describing this is that it solidifies his arguments that social institutions are the source of mankind’s bad behavior. However, at the same time he defines this true state of nature, he also brings into question whether or not it ever existed. He certainly believes it is no longer possible for it to exist. However, while the inexistence of this state might at first appear to be a disadvantage, this contradiction ultimately proves Rousseau’s point. Rousseau believes that with any social contract that comes with a sovereign power, some essence of the citizen’s freedom is given up in exchange for whatever the contract can offer them. After all, with the loss of freedom comes the loss of humanity. However, Rousseau does concede that at this point, it is in no way possible for mankind to exist without some form of society in place. Therefore, in showing the inability for the true state of nature to exist, Rousseau gives mankind something to strive for that is feasible in today's society, rather than continuing to try and achieve the
In describing the “true state of man” Rousseau often contradicts himself. The advantage of describing this is that it solidifies his arguments that social institutions are the source of mankind’s bad behavior. However, at the same time he defines this true state of nature, he also brings into question whether or not it ever existed. He certainly believes it is no longer possible for it to exist. However, while the inexistence of this state might at first appear to be a disadvantage, this contradiction ultimately proves Rousseau’s point. Rousseau believes that with any social contract that comes with a sovereign power, some essence of the citizen’s freedom is given up in exchange for whatever the contract can offer them. After all, with the loss of freedom comes the loss of humanity. However, Rousseau does concede that at this point, it is in no way possible for mankind to exist without some form of society in place. Therefore, in showing the inability for the true state of nature to exist, Rousseau gives mankind something to strive for that is feasible in today's society, rather than continuing to try and achieve the