The Great Train Robbery: Film Analysis

Improved Essays
Western’s a genre with a purpose

For almost as long as the medium of filmmaking has existed so too has the Western first showcased in Edwin S. Porter film The Great Train Robbery. Though overall a simple film in retrospect the way in which it pushed the medium forward was revolutionary in containing a narrative.
Cowboys are the initial American heroes of filmmaking which all others pull from; Westerns as a male focused genre the central genre trope of masculinity have been constructed on a cinematic level. Action heroes and noir films can be traced back to Europe either through the Sherlock Holmes books or mythic tales of heroism. The Western would also goon to instruct other genre’s such as Kurosawa’s samurai films. Through the years the
…show more content…
Focusing on the characters that have the most impact on the film’s story. Further illustrating the ways in which filmmaking techniques can create meanings reflected in the story.

First allow me to define masculinity in the Western sense. In Western narratives powerful men demonstrate their masculinity through their use of violence as the ultimate tool for resolving conflict and how their use of violence is reflective of an internal ideology. This masculinity is typically turned up to 11 in Westerns having characters killing multiple characters without remorse. The simply masculine becomes the hyper-masculine. Secondly the Western is defined where one or more characters must follow actions that align with their internal ideology often time being questioned in their code of
…show more content…
This is accomplished through his use of tight close ups and characters facial expression. Cinematography is Leone’s strong suit and he best uses it for building anticipation and suspense through silence. The music is integrated for atmospheric effect to show progression in the characters unease. Where dialogue can be utilized to illustrate a character winning the scene, Leone attempts to avoid dialogue whenever possible. Keeping it simple Leone sticks to tight close ups and blocking to show characters power. In The Good The Bad & The Ugly the three main characters have very distinct glares that inform the viewer of their character. Blondie, The Good has a poker face very focused and hard to read exemplifying his sheer confidence in controlling any given situation. Tuco, The Ugly also called the Rat by Blondie has a look like rat with his shifty eyes giving different characters short glances that mask his intention while also making his seem suspicious. Finally, Angel Eyes, The Bad who has a look similar to a snake with his eyes pointing directly at his target before a

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The genre of the Western is often classified as escapist, and in keeping with the generic expectations: deWitt’s novel is situated in the mythical West, with the action taking place in California and Oregon during the gold rush, thus following the schematics of a mid-nineteenth century Western frontier. Not only does the storyline follow that of a classic western, but the novel also boasts hired gunmen, head bosses, gold crazed prospectors, big cowboy hats, and an ending where both the protagonists ride off into the sunset (Vanja 134) –arguably a metaphor for their return to their mother. There is no doubt that Patrick deWitt’s novel The Sisters Brothers (2011) is a combination of a traditional western with a twist (Vanja 139). Although the narrative voice could be considered limited in range (Vernon 1), it carries the capability of being deadpan and often comic.…

    • 1255 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stagecoach Movie Analysis

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The “Good” vs. “Bad” Girl in Stagecoach In John Ford’s film, Stagecoach, he shows his audience the drastic difference between a lady from the East and a prostitute from the West. When the film opens, the audience meets a proper and well-behaved woman, introduced to us as Lucy Mallory, searching for her husband, “I’ve traveled all the way here from Virginia. I’m determined to get to my husband. I won’t be separated any longer” (Ford, 1939). She quickly shows that she is quite the opposite of Dallas, with the men asking her opinion and putting the drink in a separate cup from the other people in the car for her.…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why would a “charming, highborn gentleman” like Edward Pierce want to commit a crime so “startling and titillating” as the Great Train Robbery? (Crichton 7). When Pierce was asked at his trial about his motive for “planning and executing this dastardly and shocking crime,” he simply answered that he “wanted the money” (Crichton 357). Pierce’s true motivation was caused by a simple desire; instead, it was caused by his character flaws of greed and egotism. Michael Crichton captured Edward Pierce’s avarice in The Great Train Robbery by focusing on his overly self-confident, manipulative, and sly nature.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity In Tv Adverts

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Rebecca Feasey examines the representations of masculinity within television adverts. Feasey explores the representations of masculinity in relation to the hegemonic order and social context. Society have a very narrow perception of masculinity were often many traits of the everyday man is disregarded which Feasey explores within her article. Unileaver’s Lynx range was Feasey’s choice for her case due to the brand heavily promoting themselves as a very masculine product. Lynx’s adverts have challenged some of the different models of masculinity but are still promoting a false, narrow minded view of masculinity.…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Neldon Ryan Hamblin Professor Robb Kunz History 2600 September 21, 2015 Compare/contrast Assignment A common theme is ever present in both The Legacy of Conquest by Patricia Limerick and The American West by Anne Butler and Michael Lansing: a profound feeling of responsibility by the authors to set the record of the west straight and to enlighten our minds with facts and depictions of the true west. They do this by using accounts from primary sources, not the fabrications of Hollywood or “John Wayne” that we are used to seeing. However, the books differ in explaining the origin of the romanticization of the west.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dead Indian Stereotypes

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    22-Other than being classified as three different types of actors on screen, there are also three different types of ‘Indians,’ every day. Such as ‘Dead Indian,’ ‘Live Indian,’ and ‘Legal Indian.’ Starting with ‘Dead Indians,’ “but not Dead Indians I’m talking about is not deceased sort. Nor are they all that inconvenient,” (King, 53), they are known for being noble and innocent.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Male dominance in relation to female inferiority has had a lasting impression on society since early forms of entertainment. Over time, the media has developed a cultural standard and universal definition of what it means to be a man and the relevance of masculinity. In the film The Wolf of Wall Street, Jordan Belfort fulfills the definition of the quintessential macho man. His unethical behavior in muting feminism and devaluing the woman has a direct correlation to his increased value in an oversexed lifestyle and materialism.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this writing workshop, I will use three critical approaches to discuss the film, The Bicycle Thieves (De Sica, 1948). Of the six approaches, I chose the “National Cinemas”, “Auteur”, and “Ideology” approaches. The “National Cinemas” approach to analyzing film takes into account the culture and national characteristics that influence how a narrative is filmed. To understand and fully appreciate a film, one must understand the historical and cultural conditions that surround it. The writer must distinguish what makes a particular film different from those of another culture from the same time period (Corrigan, 2015).…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    SAR: “Creating The Myth” The article Creating the Myth, Linda Seger tells us what makes a good movie a great movie. Seger points out the hero myth that is portrayed in most movies and the roles they play to make the movie better. Seger tells us that all great movies have a “hero myth” behind them that usually starts with the hero living as a normal person living a normal life.…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Response Paper #3 Mise-en-scene in True Grit The movie True Grit is based back in the old western times. This is a story of a girl who seeks revenge where our main character in Mattie aims to kill Tom Chaney who has killed her father. This movie has been one, that many believe has challenged the norms of a traditional western.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity Versus Femininity in Macbeth Throughout Western history, the idea of masculinity versus femininity has been a defining aspect of society. Femininity is traditionally associated as being weak and masculinity as being strong, respectively with women and men. Despite common thought, masculinity versus femininity is nothing more than a social construct and is not black and white. Even in 17th century Scotland, such a construct played into Banquo calling the witches men, Lady Macbeth asking to be stripped of her femininity and in turn her controlling Macbeth by insulting his manhood.…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity is term that is heavily influenced by a society’s cultures and beliefs. Masculinity is also a term that could have multiple definitions depending on the way men are portrayed in certain cultures. Masculinity is defined as a set of attributes, behaviors, and roles generally associated with boys and men. Certain masculine traits include courage, independence, and assertiveness. Men are supposed to be strong, independent and not need help from anyone no matter what the circumstances are.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As far as techniques, to make the film feel more genuine, jumps and shifts are created through editing. One scene that continued to happen was the actors use of stairs and tunnels. This made the film feel that it was more than just inside a frame because it gave the film levels and depth. The use of montage is used for instance when you see the character begin to go up the stairs and then there is a cut and he is already at the top of the staircase leaving. This is an aspect that also made the film seem so realistic because you as a person know what it is like to do such actions so it makes the audience easy to relate to Antonio’s…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    According to Studlar and Bernstein (2001), John Ford advocates the cinematic poetry and sentimental narrative toward both U.S westward history and his personal experiences since nineteenth-century. The conventions of western films on narrative and characters had massive success since cinema became the mass medium, which enable to showcase the historical wild West spectacle and nostalgic sensation in films (Studlar and Bernstein, 2001). My Darling Clementine illustrates with the audience falling for the Western films. Throughout the history of American westward expansion, My Darling Clementine implicitly reflects the progress of civilization in frontier towns such as Tombstone and the turning point from wild Western to moral society. At the…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Masculine Identity Essay

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Katherine Allison WS 300 Nov. 26, 2014 The theory of exclusively masculine identity forms a collectively accepted belief or idea of how males are supposed to go about their daily lives. Masculinity is an institutionally and socially prescribed role; however, males play an active part in defining and altering masculinity. For this reason, what is considered masculine varies geographically, culturally, as well as over time. Time and again, the majority of males tend to use language, work, sports, crime, sex, etc. to construct and reconstruct gender and masculinity.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays