Obtaining The Confession: Theoretical Analysis

Superior Essays
Identification…
A crime in any magnitude is a social conflict. As an individual grows and develops, he or she is introduced to certain ideals such as right and wrong. The central ethical issue in “Obtaining the Confession” is justice, and the techniques in police interrogations in order to produce a confession which include lying to suspects, empathizing with him or her to lead them to tell the truth, offering leniency and inferring that there is a small window in which to confess in order for the suspect to secure a less severe punishment. According to John Locke, a British medical doctor and philosopher, every individual has equal liberties that include rights such as security, to protect against murder, injury, or torture, and due process
…show more content…
government uses many approaches to interrogation. A former spy stated that there were a total of 16 best used and commonly practiced techniques. There is the “direct approach” in which a suspect is simply asked the questions. Other approaches include knowledge, where the interrogator, or officer tells the suspect “we know it all.” Basically, saying that someone snitched and gave up vital information concerning the crime and the suspect needs to answer questions to preserve his or her own self-interest. The “Good cop, bad cop” approach consists of two officers taking separate sides of the suspect’s ego. The good cop, sympathizes with the suspect and the bad cop does the opposite. The “silent treatment” usually only works with unstable suspects. The rapid fire questioning approach is designed to overwhelm the suspect by interrupting their responses, and verbally exhausting them so that when the suspect finally is offered time to speak, they answer truthfully. (Augustine, 2016). Certain argument techniques such as using deductive arguing and inductive arguing to establish facts can also build a stronger offense for the suspect to attempt to defend themselves. The suspect, once taken in for questioning, would do better to cooperate and see that there must be some reason for them to be there. Using critical thinking to communicate would most likely put both officer and suspect at odds. They would both have time to evaluate the situation and have a systematic process to …show more content…
The crime, either large or small in magnitude has multiple stakeholders including the criminal, the city and its citizens. . The city and its citizens are stake holders because they pay for the police department’s security. The law enforcement agency and the person place or things involved in the crime also are stake holders because they play roles in the setting and aftermath of the crime. In the central ethical issue’s circumstance, the act of utilitarianism would be for the chief of the police to allow his officers to question the convicted sexual predator. The reason for the act would be to make the officer’s happy and the chief of police happy, unfortunately the sexual predator would not be happy either innocent or guilty because he is under the microscope. If the missing child’s parents were aware of the chief’s actions they would also be happy seeing that their tax dollars are being used to find more information to help find their son. Using non-consequential theory’s rule of natural rights, any law enforcement agency would uphold the belief of human life, health, procreation, caring for children and their welfare, knowledge and avoidance of ignorance, human relationships and the consideration of other people’s interests (Manias & Monroe,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Lisenba v, California (1941), Stein v. New York (1953), Gallegos v. Nebraska, 1951), Crooker v. California (1958), and Cicenia v. LaGay (1958) (Hemmens, 2014, p. 22). In another case, Gallegos v. Colorado (1952) the United States Supreme Court ruled that the confection a violation of due process after Gallegos who was 14 years of age at the time was denied his right to have contact with his mother (p. 22). The concerns that the cases cause among the liberal United States Supreme Court Justices consisted of cases displaying tactics by policemen in using psychological methods in getting suspects to confess (Hemmens, 2014).…

    • 396 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The legitimacy of the criminal justice system is constantly questioned and challenged by not only victims of crime, but also those of accused of committing crimes and by the public. When should someone be read their Miranda Rights? Why do a number of people confess to their crimes while others do not? What makes an interrogation legal? How are interrogations legal?…

    • 432 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Enlightenment was the root of many of the ideas of the American Revolution. It was a movement that focused mostly on freedom of speech, equality, freedom of the press, and religious tolerance. There were many enlightenment thinkers, but only 3 of many stood out to contribute to the ideas that led to the American revolution and still have an impact today. Montesquieu , John Locke, Thomas Hobbes thought different influencing American colonies, their opinions on the role of government, and how their ideas still influence us to this day.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Mississippi Case Problem

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages

    I. Jurisdiction The first step to any successful research plan is to determine in which jurisdiction the legal issue arises. Once I know the jurisdiction, I know which laws apply to the legal problem at issue. This means I must determine if the problem involves a federal issue or a state issue. If the legal problem involves a federal issue, then I must use federal laws and cases from federal courts to resolve the issue.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    . Another very important piece of policing that has also evolved with the times is police interrogation methods. An interrogation is when someone examines a suspect by questioning them formally. The biggest difference in interrogation methods used in the past compared to the more modern method is between the confrontational and non-confrontational methods. Confrontational interrogation, also known as the Reid Technique, is an aggressive way to obtain a confession.…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sandra Bland Case Analysis

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The article refrains from accusing the police of violence towards Sandra Bland. Instead, the article focuses on the perspective of police investigators. The investigators are bewildered of the cause of Sandra Bland 's death and appear to be doing the best to discover the cause. The focus from police investigators reinforces positive characteristics about law enforcement, such as hard working in bringing justice to citizens. This illustrates law enforcements as blameless because these officials are represented as eager to solve the case.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Socratic practice, as presented in The Apology through Socrates’s explanation of it and his way of implementing it, relies on its implementer being perceived as truthful and disinterested in wealth, while simultaneously questioning the perceived knowledge amongst individuals of authority. Socrates’s form of philosophical discussion forced the burden of the conversation upon his opponents though this questioning. In the Republic, Socrates provides an apt example of the Socratic practice as he argues against Thrasymachus. The first and foremost aspect of Socrates’s rhetoric is that he claims to speak only the truth. In the Apology, Socrates begins his speech by saying to his fellow Athenians that “From me you will hear the whole truth,…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The criminal justice system often is examined using political, organizational, or sociological approaches [or lenses] (Pollock, 2010). Asking [simply] whether something is legal [or illegal]…is not necessarily the same question as asking whether something is right [or wrong] (Pollock, 2010). The term “ethics” or “ethical” refers to something “being in accordance with the accepted principles of right and wrong that govern the conduct of a profession.” In the case of police officers, use of discretion, or a lack thereof, in the application of force has direct ethical consequences to which the objectivity of the police officer on scene is subjugated by the subjectivity of a review board after the fact. Actors at every stage in the justice process…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Incomplete Characterization of Motives In Confessions, Augustine stated that the motive behind all actions was lust of different types. He divided lust into three categories: lust for domination, lust of the eyes, and lust for sensuality. Augustine defined lust for domination as the desire to control people or properties. Lust of the eyes was the desire to satiate the senses: sight, smell, taste, touch, and hearing.…

    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine a Haitian family, who has risked their lives to cross the expanse of ocean over seven hundred miles long in order to pursue a better life once they reach the shores of Florida. They desire refugee status and one day, citizenship. Upon reaching the end of their perilous journey, they are allowed to stay in the United States, but are immediately issued fines that they cannot possibly afford to pay, simply for indecent exposure and disturbing the peace. Though most people would consider this to be an undesirable outcome, in his work “Second Treatise of Government” published in 1689, John Locke suggests that in order to enjoy the advantages one receives from living under a government’s control, one must consent to the laws of that government. In this paper I shall discuss Locke’s idea of tacit consent, and consider its weaknesses as well as possible strengths if one were examine Locke’s “tacit consent” with a fairly generous interpretation of his intended meaning; Locke’s argument will then be compared to the views of the twentieth century philosophers Martin Luther King Jr and Martha Nussbaum.…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Comparing Reid Interview Technique and the PEACE Model Dominic Wood Police Foundations Interview and investigations Amy Bjerkens October 03 2017 Comparing Reid Interviewing technique and the PEACE model While the Reid model aims at obtaining a confession from the witness or suspect, the PEACE Model aims at getting the information that will help in determining the guiltiness or the innocence of the subject. Whereas the Reid model is interrogator-based and follows what is dictated by nature and the reactions of the subject, the PEACE Model is a step by step process which is preplanned in the mind of the interrogator. The Reid interviewing model is based on body language while the PEACE Model is founded on deceiving the subject…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Summary Of Picking Cotton

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages

    14 Ronald Cotton, who spent eleven years in prison for a crime he didn’t commit, was supposed to live in an average life. How an innocent man was put into prison? Where is the justice that we often talk about? Whenever I read the book Picking Cotton, I feel my heart beating very strongly for what Ronald suffered. However, Ronald’s case is not isolated.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On March 3, 1963, in Phoenix, Arizona, Lois Ann Jameson, an 18 year old woman, was attacked on her way home from her night job. The attacker not only yanked her into his car, but also drove out to the desert and raped her. Afterwards, she got dropped off near her house. On March 13, Ernesto Miranda was apprehended in his house and brought to the police station to be investigated for rape and kidnapping. Within two hours, he signed a confession stating that he was the one that committed the crimes without knowing his full rights.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When a crime takes place, authorities’ number one priority is to obtain a confession. Unfortunately, in order to do this, investigators use mental manipulation on their suspects. Interrogators would keep the person in a room for hours, and continuously accuse them of a crime that sometimes the person being interrogated did not commit. This pressure would result on an individual giving a false confession. According to the Innocence Project (2014) people usually give out false confession because they believe that if they comply with the police, it will benefit them and help them prove their innocence in the future.…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Pain and punishment are two words that interweave with each other in accordance with criminal justice. However, the way an individual is able to interpret these words can develop very different, and influential forms of thinking. Nevertheless, these developed forms of thinking allow individuals to form opinions on the subject, and aid in the formation our state. In this essay I am going to be explaining both Immanuel Kant, and Jeremy Bentham’s individual stances on punishment. This will include the theories of retributivism, and deterrence as leading factors to explain each theory.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays