Socrates argues that justice can only be realized through the moderation of the soul. Again, this will be reflected upon the city. Glaucon and Ademantus argue that the benefit or lack of justice does not always affects a person’s happiness. They start off with a positive view of justice where Glaucon wants Socrates to prove that it is good. Glaucon makes the point that if it is just to do wrong in order to achieve justice, then a man who lies or cheats but is a respected person, is living a just life. This is when Socrates brings in the comparison of the three parts of the soul to the city. Socrates speaks of three cities: the cities of necessity, luxury, and fever. The city of necessity only contains what is needed for survival, such as food, shelter, and clothing. Of course, this city will need laborers to produce the necessary materials. Eventually, the laborers produce more than what is consumed and expand to comfort, creating a city of luxury. This city desires more such as larger more comfortable houses and furniture. The demand for luxury leads to a feverish city in which the desires of the people cannot be completely fulfilled causing unhappiness among the
Socrates argues that justice can only be realized through the moderation of the soul. Again, this will be reflected upon the city. Glaucon and Ademantus argue that the benefit or lack of justice does not always affects a person’s happiness. They start off with a positive view of justice where Glaucon wants Socrates to prove that it is good. Glaucon makes the point that if it is just to do wrong in order to achieve justice, then a man who lies or cheats but is a respected person, is living a just life. This is when Socrates brings in the comparison of the three parts of the soul to the city. Socrates speaks of three cities: the cities of necessity, luxury, and fever. The city of necessity only contains what is needed for survival, such as food, shelter, and clothing. Of course, this city will need laborers to produce the necessary materials. Eventually, the laborers produce more than what is consumed and expand to comfort, creating a city of luxury. This city desires more such as larger more comfortable houses and furniture. The demand for luxury leads to a feverish city in which the desires of the people cannot be completely fulfilled causing unhappiness among the